Subway’s Market Share Crumbles as Rivals Rise

Article Summary

Subway’s dominance in the sub sandwich category has eroded dramatically, with its market share falling from 56% in 2019 to just 44% in 2024—a 21% drop over five years. While the chain has closed 2,600 stores, the decline isn’t solely due to unit reductions. Competitors like Jersey Mike’s and Firehouse Subs are gaining organic sales at existing locations, signaling a shift in consumer loyalty. Subway’s domestic system sales fell 7.5%, while the overall sub sandwich category grew 19%, indicating that customers are migrating to other brands. The company’s long-standing focus on low prices has backfired, making current pricing seem steep. Franchisees are struggling, with many refusing discounts or cutting staff to survive. The brand’s outdated business model—once emulated by rivals like Quiznos and Blimpie—has proven unsustainable in today’s market. Subway’s challenges include leadership voids, PR scandals, and a failure to adapt to evolving consumer expectations.

Full article here

Local Business Types for Broadcasters to Consider Contacting

Independent Sandwich Shops – These businesses can leverage Subway’s decline by promoting fresh ingredients, local ownership, and personalized service through broadcast storytelling.
Regional Fast-Casual Chains – With consumers shifting toward quality and experience, these brands can use radio and TV to highlight their unique offerings and community ties.
Local Butcher Shops and Delis – As freshness and quality become key differentiators, these businesses can advertise their premium meats and sandwich ingredients to attract lunch crowds and build brand loyalty.

Three Creative Campaign Ideas for Broadcasters to Consider

Radio Station Commercial Idea: “Substitute Your Sub” – A campaign inviting listeners to try local sandwich shops instead of national chains, featuring taste tests, customer stories, and weekly giveaways.
TV Station Commercial Idea: “Fresh Takes on Lunch” – A visual series spotlighting regional sandwich makers and their signature creations, emphasizing freshness, flavor, and local pride.
Digital Advertising Campaign Idea: “Build Your Own Sub Challenge” – A social media contest where users design their dream sandwich using local ingredients, with winners featured in digital ads and rewarded by participating restaurants.